Photo by tom owens

Shelter Island Hotels

your current months are December, 2024 and January, 2025.
December 2024
January 2025

Find and book your perfect stay

Earn rewards on every night you stay
Save more with Member Prices
Free cancellation options if plans change

Where to stay in Shelter Island?

Sunset Beach Hotel
Exterior

Sunset Beach Hotel

2.0 star property
9.2 out of 10, Wonderful, (17)
Sunset Beach Hotel
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Top neighborhoods in Shelter Island

Default Image

Silver Beach

Shelter Island's Silver Beach neighbourhood offers attractions, including Shell Beach.

See properties
Silver Beach

Top landmarks in Shelter Island

Mashomack Preserve

Mashomack Preserve is 1.3 mi (2.1 km) from central Shelter Island, why not stop by during your stay? Want to stretch your legs a little more? Head to Sag Harbor Marine Park and Norman E. Klipp Marine Park, both nearby.

See properties
Mashomack Preserve

Frequently asked questions

Can I book a refundable accommodation option in Shelter Island?
If you want the flexibility to change your plans to Shelter Island, most hotels offer refundable* rates that you can book. You can find these properties by searching our site and using the “fully refundable” filter to narrow the results down.
Where can I stay in Shelter Island if I want a holiday rental instead of a hotel?
If you want a good alternative to a hotel, browse our selection of 85 holiday homes.
What will the weather in Shelter Island be like during my visit?
The warmest months in Shelter Island are usually August and July, with an average temperature of 21°C. January and February are the chilliest months, when the average temperature is 3°C. The rainiest months are October and December.
Why should I book my Shelter Island hotel with Hotels.com?
There are plenty of reasons to book your Shelter Island travel with us: our free cancellations on selected hotels* gives you the flexibility you’re looking for, our Price Guarantee ensures that you always get the lowest price, and you can earn rewards on every booking.